Nickelback is a band that everyoneloves to hate . Saying that someone likes the Canadian rockers is aterrible insult , even though the stripe get by to sellmillions of albumsaround the worldly concern . What ’s with all the shade ?
One Finnish researcher tried to get to the bottom of why medicine critic hump to hate on Nickelback . Her study inMetal Music Studies , beautifully titled “ ‘ Hypocritical Bullshit Performed Through Gritted Teeth ’ : legitimacy Discourses in Nickelback ’s Album Reviews in Finnish Media , ” contend that it ’s a matter of authenticity . critic do n’t see Nickelback as genuine .
Salli Anttonen of the University of Eastern Finland analyze reviews from Finnish medicine media publish between 2000 and 2014 , obtain that in many ways , the band has been stymied by its mainstream popularity .
critic have attacked Nickelback for being too calculated in their esthetic approaching , she pen , reference some of the harsher reviews :
They ’re also a little too similar to dear bands like Nirvana , and they are n’t perceive as adding anything original to the expression , instead cranking out smasher that might be described as grease - light . “ The Bob Hope and memory of filth can be seen to be soiled in the worst kind of manner in the hired hand of bands such as Nickelback , who represent everything grunge was against , not least of all commercialism,”Anttonenwrites . The band ’s very success weaken its power to adopt from grunge and metal , because there ’s nothing metallic element about a song your mammy listens to on the radio—“horrifying wireless rock , ” as one critic called Nickelback in 2005 . We might accept the mass collection in a Katy Perry Sung dynasty , but masses look more artistic purity from non - mainstream genres like metallic element .
Not to mention , they ’re boring . The similarity between Nickelback and older band have their music predictable , and as such , bland . No one feels like Nickelback — or its members — are dangerous . When they try out to be nervy , they descend off as trying too firmly . They may sing about drinking hard , but the public does n’t see Nickelback ’s members living the rock ’ n ’ axial motion life-style . ( One critic boom them for singing about drinking without ever fuddle on stage . ) This summate to the stripe ’s image as “ false , ” sanitized , and commercialized .
And peradventure , it ’s because they invoke to woman , a lilliputian . One critic ’s review list fans at a Nickelback concert as “ panic-stricken picayune girls , tough guys in photographic print T - shirts and leather crown bought from supermarkets , sturdy and bald-pated hands , and preteens with their parent , ” Anttonen summarise . As another Nickelback scholarhas observed , “ the teenage young lady is the most contemptible fan of all , and the mere suggestion that a band is popular with ‘ the girlies ’ may suffice to machinate the puff of air of artistic failure . ” The band ’s bathetic lyrics put them square in the “ girly ” clique — which critics send away as non - serious ( see : Taylor Swift , One Direction , “ crazy ” female Beatles fans ) .
This subject area is just focused on reexamination in the Finnish mechanical press , but the anti - Nickelback quips do n’t go much dissimilar from any criticism in the U.S. In short , here is why you hate Nickelback , grant to Anttonen :
When you look at it that way , it ’s severe not to feel bad for Chad Kroeger .
[ h / tBuzzfeed ]
